Today's Reviews

๐ŸŸข 8 Bullish
๐ŸŸก 2 Neutral
๐Ÿ”ด 2 Bearish
๐Ÿ“… 19 Nov 2026
NEUTRAL
Sanlam Limited (SLM)
9-month update โ€” new business +20% but earnings flat
โ† Previous: BULLISH on 04 Nov
New business volumes grew 20% and net client cash flows surged 37% to R108 billion. But core earnings only rose 1% and value of new covered business fell 13%, reflecting margin pressure.

Sanlam's 9-month update is the definition of mixed. The top-line metrics are excellent โ€” new business volumes up 20%, net client cash flows up 37% to R108 billion โ€” but the bottom line tells a different story. Core earnings inched up just 1%, operating profit excluding investment variances fell 1%, and the value of new covered business dropped 13% to R1.5 billion with margins compressed to 1.7%. The message is that Sanlam is selling more but earning less on each sale, which is the classic insurance industry squeeze.

The discretionary capital balance of R1.9 billion and economic solvency cover within target range provide comfort, but the market wants to see earnings growth, not just asset gathering. At R76.53 the stock is down 9.6% in a month and the market is questioning the earnings trajectory. Neutral because the asset gathering story is strong but the earnings conversion is not there yet.

R7653.00 at review
At review: R7,653.00 Now: R7,653.00 Total return: -9.6% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISH
Shoprite Holdings Limited (SHP)
Collapse of the non-economic voting structure โ€” goodbye Wiese era
โ† Previous: BULLISH on 09 Nov
Shoprite announced a proposed transaction to collapse the existing non-economic voting structure linked to Christo Wiese's Titan/Thibault entities, simplifying the share structure and removing a governance overhang.

This is the biggest news on the JSE today, and it is not close. Shoprite has been carrying a bizarre dual-class voting structure since the Wiese era โ€” deferred shares that gave Titan/Thibault outsized voting power without economic exposure. That structure has been a governance stain for years, and Shoprite is finally killing it. The deal is complex โ€” a specific issue of shares to Titan in exchange for them acquiring the Wiese-related parties' ordinary shares and cancelling the deferred shares โ€” but the outcome is simple: one share, one vote.

The Independent Board, chaired by Wendy Lucas-Bull, has blessed the transaction and recommends shareholders vote in favour. The circular goes out on 10 December and the general meeting is set for 19 January 2027. At R335.81, Shoprite is already the best-run retailer in Africa, and removing this governance overhang only makes it more attractive to institutional investors who have been sitting on the sidelines. Bullish because this unlocks the next leg of re-rating.

R33581.00 at review
At review: R33,581.00 Now: R33,581.00 Total return: +1.9% Dividends: R0.00
BEARISHGhost: 28 Oct
Quantum Foods Holdings Limited (QFH)
Incident at Hartebeespoort Hatchery
โ† Previous: BULLISH on 27 Oct
Quantum Foods reported an unspecified incident at its Hartebeespoort hatchery. The nature and financial impact are not yet quantified, but any operational disruption at a key facility is a risk.

Quantum Foods disclosed an incident at its Hartebeespoort hatchery without providing details on the nature or financial impact. That vagueness is the problem โ€” when a company reports an 'incident' without quantifying it, the market has to assume the worst until told otherwise. The hatchery is a critical part of Quantum Foods' poultry operations, and any disruption to the supply chain means lost production, higher costs and potential contract penalties.

At R8.79 the stock is down 1.7% in a month, but the real damage will only become clear when Quantum quantifies the hit. The lack of detail suggests management is still assessing the damage, and until they provide clarity, the uncertainty will weigh on the share price. Bearish because uncertainty is the enemy of share prices and this smells worse than management is letting on.

R879.00 at review
At review: R879.00 Now: R879.00 Total return: -1.7% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISH
Prosus N.V. (PRX)
Trading statement โ€” Adj EPS +11-15%, investing through the cycle
โ† Previous: BULLISH on 08 Oct
Adjusted earnings per share up 11-15% to 178 cents, headline EPS up 30-39%, but basic EPS negative on investment write-downs. Prosus is investing hard in iFood and JET for the long term.

The headline numbers are a mess โ€” EPS down 19-28% โ€” but that is because Prosus is spending money on purpose. Adjusted earnings, which strips out the noise, came in 11-15% higher at 178 cents, and headline earnings surged 30-39%. The story is simple: iFood and Just Eat Takeaway are in investment mode, building out their ecosystems in LatAm and Europe. This is not a company in trouble; it is a company that can afford to buy growth.

The market will punish the stock in the short term because the market hates spending without immediate payoff. But Prosus has the balance sheet, the Tencent stake, and the track record to make this work. At R613 it is off its highs and the long-term thesis is intact. Bullish because the adjusted numbers tell the truth and the investments are strategic, not desperate.

R61300.00 at review
At review: R61,300.00 Now: R61,300.00 Total return: -6.4% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISH
Netcare Limited (NTC)
Trading statement for FY2026 โ€” EPS +16-20%, HEPS +19-22%
โ† Previous: NEUTRAL on 30 Sep
Netcare reported EPS of 157-162 cents (up 16-20%), HEPS of 158-163 cents (up 19-22%), driven by higher activity, operational efficiencies and the share buyback programme.

Netcare delivered a clean set of numbers โ€” no write-offs, no exceptional items, just more patients, better margins, and a share buyback doing the maths. EPS of 157 to 162 cents against 135 cents last year is a 16-20% improvement, and adjusted HEPS of 158 to 163 cents is up 15-19%. The company credited increased activity, sustained operational efficiencies and the digital dividend โ€” management-speak for 'we are running this business properly'.

At R19.10 the stock trades on roughly 12 times earnings for a hospital group with pricing power, a defensive patient base and a balance sheet that allows for buybacks. The full results land on Monday 23 November, and if the trading statement is anything to go by, they will be worth reading. Bullish because private healthcare in SA is a compounding machine and Netcare is running it well.

R1910.00 at review
At review: R1,910.00 Now: R1,910.00 Total return: +7.7% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISHGhost: 22 Jun
Naspers Limited (NPN)
Trading statement โ€” mirroring Prosus, same investment cycle
โ† Previous: BULLISH on 08 Oct
Naspers released its trading statement alongside Prosus, reflecting the same investment cycle in iFood and JET. Adjusted earnings expected to show mid-teens growth.

Naspers and Prosus move as one โ€” the trading statements dropped simultaneously at 17:45, which tells you everything about the structure. The adjusted earnings picture is positive, headline earnings are strong, and the basic EPS figure is distorted by investment spend. The market has been punishing both stocks โ€” NPN down 6% in a month โ€” because the narrative around tech has soured globally.

But this is the same Naspers that has compounded capital for decades. The Tencent stake alone is worth more than the current market cap of the holding company, which means you get the ecommerce portfolio for free. That is a discount that will close when the investment cycle matures. Bullish because the sum-of-the-parts math is too compelling to ignore at these levels.

R65800.00 at review
At review: R65,800.00 Now: R65,800.00 Total return: -6.1% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISH
Lewis Group Limited (LEW)
H1 results โ€” revenue +7.2%, dividend declared 375 cents
โ† Previous: NEUTRAL on 21 Oct
Lewis reported H1 revenue up 7.2% to R5.2 billion and declared a cash dividend of 375 cents per share. The furniture retailer continues to execute well in a tough consumer environment.

Lewis Group put out a clean set of interim numbers: revenue up 7.2% to R5.2 billion and a cash dividend of 375 cents per share. In an economy where consumers are under pressure from high interest rates and fuel prices, Lewis is managing to grow because it serves a market that the banks ignore โ€” the cash and credit customer base that needs furniture and cannot get store cards from the major retailers.

The dividend declaration is the most important number in this statement: 375 cents per share at a share price of R95 gives a yield of nearly 4%, and management would not pay that unless they were confident about the second half. The stock is up 10% in a month, and at these levels it still trades on a reasonable multiple with a real dividend. Bullish because Lewis is boring, predictable and profitable โ€” exactly the kind of stock that compounds quietly.

R9500.00 at review
At review: R9,500.00 Now: R9,500.00 Total return: +10.2% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISH
Investec Limited (INL)
H1 results โ€” deposits +6.8%, loans +5.2%, cash dividend declared
โ† Previous: BULLISH on 21 Sep
Investec reported H1 results with customer deposits up 6.8% to ยฃ22.8bn and net core loans up 5.2% to ยฃ18.3bn. A cash dividend was declared, reflecting solid capital generation.

Investec's interim numbers are steady rather than spectacular, but steady is exactly what you want from a diversified financial group in the current environment. Customer deposits grew 6.8% to ยฃ22.8 billion and net core loans rose 5.2% to ยฃ18.3 billion โ€” both measured in sterling, which matters because the weak rand makes the SA numbers look better than the underlying reality. The group declared a cash dividend, which is the signal that matters most: management is confident enough in the capital position to return money to shareholders.

At R125.84, Investec trades on a single-digit P/E with a decent dividend yield and a dual-listed structure that gives investors exposure to both the UK and SA economies. The risk is that the UK wealth and asset management division faces fee pressure in a low-growth environment. But the balance sheet is strong, the loan book is performing and the dividend is real. Bullish because boring banks that pay dividends and grow book value are the best compounders on the JSE.

R12584.00 at review
At review: R12,584.00 Now: R12,584.00 Total return: -0.9% Dividends: R0.00
BEARISHReview #1
eMedia Holdings Limited (EMH)
Trading statement โ€” HEPS down 50-57% as TV ad revenue crumbles
eMedia reported headline earnings per share down 50-57% to 11.5-13.5 cents. EPS was flat at 26.5-28.5 cents thanks to a land sale. The core problem: television advertising revenue is disappearing.

eMedia's trading statement is a window into the slow death of linear television in South Africa. Headline earnings per share collapsed by 50-57% because the 'archaic television audience measurement system' โ€” management's words, not mine โ€” is failing to capture viewership and advertisers are voting with their feet. The company sold land at Cape Town Film Studios and Dreamworld Management to prop up the earnings line, but headline earnings strips that out and the picture is brutal.

At R2.10 the stock looks cheap on EPS of 27 cents, but that is a trap โ€” the EPS number includes the land sale gain and the underlying business is shrinking. Television is a structurally declining industry, and eMedia does not have the digital assets to offset the losses. Bearish because there is no catalyst to reverse the advertising revenue decline and management is selling assets to paper over the cracks.

R210.00 at review
At review: R210.00 Now: R210.00 Total return: +5.5% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISH
City Lodge Hotels Limited (CLH)
4-month voluntary update โ€” occupancy holds, room rates up 9%
โ† Previous: NEUTRAL on 10 Sep
City Lodge reported 62.8% occupancy (up 0.8pp), average room rates up 9%, F&B revenue up 11%, and total RevPAR up 11%. Net debt is only R61 million.

City Lodge keeps delivering exactly what the hospitality sector should deliver in a constrained economy: more people in rooms, paying higher rates, and keeping costs under control. Occupancy hit 62.8% for the four months to October, up from 62% in the prior period โ€” and the prior period included the B20 and G20 summits that drove extraordinary demand. That the numbers are higher without those events is genuinely impressive.

Average room rates rose 9%, F&B revenue jumped 11%, and total revenue per available room is up 11%. The balance sheet is in its best shape in years โ€” net debt of only R61 million against a R60 million dividend paid in the prior year. At R4.32 the stock is flat over the past month, but the operating trajectory is clear. Bullish because the fundamentals are solid and the market is not paying attention.

R432.00 at review
At review: R432.00 Now: R432.00 Total return: -0.5% Dividends: R0.00
NEUTRAL
Crookes Brothers Limited (CKS)
Trading statement โ€” EPS +60-70% but HEPS down 88-98% on sugar imports
โ† Previous: NEUTRAL on 23 Sep
EPS up 60-70% to 206-219 cents thanks to an impairment reversal on Mozambican macadamia operations. Headline earnings, which excludes that reversal, collapsed 88-98% as cheap sugar imports hammered the core business.

This is a study in why headline earnings matter. Crookes Brothers reported EPS up 60-70%, which sounds fantastic until you read that the increase is driven entirely by reversing a prior impairment on macadamia operations that are now classified as held for sale. Headline earnings โ€” the number that measures the actual trading performance โ€” crashed by 88-98% because cheap sugar imports from the global market are destroying the SACU sugar price. Industrial action at South African mills made it worse, delaying deliveries and pushing revenue into the second half.

The banana segment did well, but bananas are not big enough to move the needle. At R23.50 the stock looks optically cheap on EPS, but the headline earnings story is ugly and there is no quick fix for the sugar import problem. Neutral because the impairment reversal is a one-off that flatters the numbers, and the underlying business is under genuine pressure.

R2350.00 at review
At review: R2,350.00 Now: R2,350.00 Total return: +12.5% Dividends: R0.00
BULLISH
Cafca Limited (CAC)
FY results โ€” profit +152%, revenue +32%, dividend declared
โ† Previous: BULLISH on 14 Aug
CAFCA reported a 152% increase in profit to US$4.7 million and a 32% revenue increase driven by 24% volume growth. Aluminium cable volumes surged 56% as Zimbabwe's mining boom drove demand.

CAFCA is a Zimbabwean cable manufacturer that operates in US dollars and benefits from everything the pessimists get wrong about Zimbabwe. Revenue grew 32%, profit surged 152% to US$4.7 million, and sales volumes jumped 24% โ€” led by 56% growth in aluminium cables and conductors. The mining boom in Zimbabwe โ€” gold, platinum, lithium โ€” is driving real infrastructure demand, and CAFCA is the local supplier.

The operating environment is stable: annual ZiG inflation collapsed from 82.7% to 3.7%, the exchange rate held, and the company generated US$6.48 million in operating cash flow, up 120%. At R7.90 the market is pricing in Zimbabwe risk that the numbers are disproving quarter by quarter. Bullish because a business growing profit 152%, generating cash and operating in hard currency deserves a higher multiple.

R790.00 at review
At review: R790.00 Now: R790.00 Total return: +0.0% Dividends: R0.00