Zeda โ the car rental and fleet management group that emerged from the old Avis stable โ issued its year-end trading statement and the numbers confirm what the share price does not believe: this is a profitable, cash-generating business trading at a distressed multiple. At R16.31 and 4.3 times trailing earnings with a 21.3% ROE and a price-to-book of 0.88, the market is treating Zeda like a business that will not survive the next downturn. But car rental is a volume-and-utilisation game, and Zeda has been running the playbook: managing fleet costs, keeping utilisation high, and generating free cash flow.
The year-end statement does not give precise EPS ranges in the scraper output, but the direction is clear enough. At 4.3 times earnings and below book, the market has already priced in a recession. If the consumer holds up through the festive season โ and the CMH numbers suggest the motor trade is still motoring โ Zeda will print the numbers that force a re-rating. Cheap is not a catalyst, but it is a margin of safety, and in this market that counts for something.
Vukile successfully completed its accelerated bookbuild, and the timing is neat: Ghost Mail's latest post ("Vukile's Gateway to Growth") covers exactly this story, noting the fund is raising equity to fund its development pipeline in SA and its Spanish exposure through the Europa Capital platform. An accelerated bookbuild that goes well tells you two things: institutional demand for the paper is real, and the discount the issuer had to offer was small enough that existing holders did not feel fleeced. The fact that Vukile went to market and got the deal done in a single day says the institutional bid is there.
At R24.86 the stock trades on 5.6 times earnings and at exactly book value. For a retail landlord with an 18.7% ROE and a growing Spanish platform, that is too cheap โ the bookbuild creates near-term dilution but funds the growth that justifies the re-rating. Vukile is not a mall owner in a dying sector; it is a retail property fund that picked the right markets (Western Cape, Spain) and is betting on physical retail in places where it still works. The bookbuild says institutions agree.
Telkom reported its H1 numbers and the story is the same one that has been quietly working for two years: Openserve keeps connecting fibre, BCX keeps winning enterprise contracts, and the mobile business stops losing money. The group is not growing at Silicon Valley rates โ it is a fixed-line incumbent with a mobile arm in a tough consumer economy โ but it is generating real cash from assets that would cost a fortune to replicate. The interim results landed at 07:15 and the stock barely budged, which is the Telkom experience in a nutshell: consistently better than the narrative, consistently ignored by a market that remembers the years it was broken.
At R69.48 the stock trades on 9.8 times earnings with a price-to-book of 0.97. That is a state-owned telco with a fibre monopoly in large parts of the country trading at book value and generating a double-digit return on equity. The risks are real โ the SA consumer, spectrum allocation politics, the cost of Eskom backup โ but the multiple already prices in catastrophe. If Telkom delivers a full year of the trajectory these interims suggest, the re-rating will come from the numbers doing the talking, not management.
Sasol is doing what a company with a stretched balance sheet should do: getting ahead of its maturities. The new US$750 million guaranteed senior unsecured convertible bonds due 2032 come with a concurrent offer to buy back the existing US$750 million 4.5% convertible bonds due 2027. Net debt stays exactly where it is โ you are swapping one bond for another, five years later โ but the company locks in financing through 2032 at a time when its operational momentum (best mining quarter in six years, ORYX back online, NERSA gas pricing clarity) gives it a better negotiating hand than it had when it issued the 2027s.
The market marked Sasol up to R223.00, which is a gentle nod of approval for a refinancing that removes a near-term wall of debt without diluting equity. The conversion premium on the new bonds will determine whether this is a cheap refinancing or an expensive one โ but the key metric is that Sasol is not asking shareholders for money. It is asking the bond market, and the bond market said yes. At 11.9 times trailing earnings and below book value, Sasol is cheap for a chemicals-and-energy group that has stopped breaking things. This is the right kind of financial engineering: boring, sensible and maturity-extending.
NEPI Rockcastle filed its Q3 business update late in the day and the headline is that its Central and Eastern European shopping centre portfolio keeps doing what it does: collecting rent, managing occupancy, and benefiting from a region where disposable income is growing faster than Western Europe. The detail in a Q3 business update from a REIT is usually light โ it is a narrative update, not a full set of numbers โ and the stock at R145.50 already reflects the quality of the portfolio and the management team.
The risk is currency and interest rates: NEPI reports in euros and the rand hedge works both ways. At 10.1 times earnings and 1.1 times book, it is priced fairly for a REIT with genuine asset quality in markets that are growing. But it is also a stock that has run hard, and a Q3 update that says "things are fine" is not the catalyst that drives the next leg. NEUTRAL โ good business, fair price, no catalyst.
Nictus is a tiny JSE-listed retailer โ market cap of R134 million, stock at R2.50, trading on 3.6 times earnings and 0.81 times book. The trading statement for the six months to September is a regulatory box-tick for a company this small, and the numbers are unlikely to move a stock that trades a few thousand rand a day. The 24.7% ROE suggests the business is not broken โ it is just very, very small.
NEUTRAL because nothing in a micro-cap trading statement changes the investment case for a stock that nobody owns and nobody trades. The 3.6 times PE is either a screaming bargain or a value trap, and on a stock this illiquid, the only way to find out is to buy enough to move the price. That is not an investment thesis โ it is a liquidity event waiting to happen.
Coronation is the kind of business that makes you wonder why the JSE does not have more asset managers listed. The full-year numbers for the year to September show a fund manager that keeps generating returns on equity that most industrial companies would kill for โ 68.8% ROE on a stock trading at 8.3 times earnings. The dividend declaration confirms the cash is real, and the business model (manage other people's money, collect fees, pay out what you do not need) means capital allocation is simple: pay a dividend, buy back shares when the discount to intrinsic value is wide enough.
At R39.36 the market is valuing Coronation at barely 5.4 times book despite nearly 69% ROE. That is a 12.8% earnings yield on a business with no debt, no inventory, and a client list that includes the biggest pension funds in the country. The risk is flows: if clients redeem, the fee income shrinks. But Coronation has been through multiple cycles of retail and institutional redemptions and kept compounding. This is a quality compounder trading at a price that assumes the good years are behind it. They are not.